"Self-directed children use reason like a sword to cut through these external distractions
so they're free to make their choices because those choices are right."
Now, more than ever before, it 's painfully obvious that many of the world's children
would rather die or kill than not fit in. Although these few represent the extreme, what
about our own children? What kind of pressure do they feel to belong, to be popular, to
be worthy of their peer group? That's an easy, one-word answer: intense. Okay, maybe two
words, then: very intense. Sure, we're frantically searching for ways to quell the
horrific fallout that occurs when children are rejected, teased, and bullied by their
peers by counseling the victims and the predators, by tightening school security, by
homeschooling our kids and so on. But this is like trimming the withering tips of the
branches on a very sick tree. Why don't we look to the roots to cure that tree by asking
ourselves, What drives our kids to require peer acceptance and approval?
To understand this root, let's examine another-the root of human behavior. We are,
much like wolves and dogs, pack animals. Okay, so we don't howl at the moon, roll
in nasty stuff or sniff inappropriate body parts, but we do have one vital pack
animal instinct-the urge to belong to our pack. In our case, we may have many
packs-our neighbors, our co-workers, our gender, our friends or all of humanity,
but in the case of our children, their most influential pack is their peer group.
There are two ways to satisfy that urge for pack acceptance:
- To earn it by coming up with a unique contribution or meaningful role that betters
the pack's welfare
- To beg for it by pleasing the pack, conforming with the pack, abiding by those
arbitrary and often warped standards of worthiness that the pack thrusts in our faces.
Sadly, most of humanity has chosen the latter one, probably because it's easier
to let someone else think for us. Also, over the centuries, requiring people to
think and act a certain way has been a convenient way for our leaders to dominate
the unruly, uncivilized masses. The Spanish Inquisition. Need I say more?
So instead of raising self-directed children who make their choices based on
internal cues like their morals, their values, their past experiences and their
concept of self, we've been raising externally directed children who rely on the
outside word, like their peers, the media, song lyrics and movies, as guiding
beacons. And yep, we've been doing it for centuries.
Self-directed children use reason like a sword to cut through these external distractions
so they're free to make their choices because those choices are right. Externally directed
children make whatever choice is necessary to win acceptance and approval. And to do that,
they use all the choice distortion tools at their disposal-excuses, self-deceit, denial,
rationalizations, justifications, etc. This makes it easy for them to act on impulse, to
shirk responsibility, to thumb their noses at accountability, and to succumb to every
temptation, whim, mood or desire. Look around you at the world today. Read the paper.
Watch the evening news. It's tragically clear what the repercussions for this choice
mechanism are.
So what can we do? Simple. We can teach our children how to think for themselves-
to recover their true power of thought, to learn how to be rewarded with
acceptance as a consequence of their contributions instead of needing acceptance
and thereby conforming.
This concept can be disseminated through many avenues quite easily. In fact, a pilot
program is in the planning stages that would include "self-direction skills" in elementary
school curricula. For those who want immediate intervention for their own children,
Raising Children Who Think for Themselves, provides practical parenting strategies that
encourage self-direction in children. If we're successful, and we will be, we'll proudly
bless our children with a safer, happier and saner future. A world that they deserve.
© 2001, Elisa Medhus, MD. All Rights Reserved. Published by permission.
Dr. Elisa Medhus, MD, is the author of Raising Children Who Think for Themselves,
which will be pubished may 10, 2001. She believes strongly that children need to
learn the skills that allow them to make self-directed choices, rather than relying
on external approval as a guide to decision-making. In pursuit of that goal, Dr.Medhus
in the process of developing a pilot program for 4th and 5th graders that includes weekly
interactive minicurriculum on how they can develop the tools of self-direction and avoid
externally directed thinking.